I’ll begin this post by saying that I’m not a foodie. A friend of mine works in the restaurant industry and was recently asking me all of these questions about his pop-up and how much he should charge and I was basically useless. Do I like fun, Instagrammable places that happen to be tasty? Yes. But do I enjoy spending money on food, going out to nice dinners, cooking, or even paying $10 for a work lunch? No way. However, when I’m traveling, I’m always eager to check out local places, try the food that everyone is raving about (or let’s be real…Instagramming), etc, even if it’s a little overpriced. When I was in NYC a couple of weeks ago, I hit several of my favorite spots as well as some new finds that I’ll definitely be going back to next time!
Ess-a-Bagel: I sadly didn’t take a picture of my bagel, but that was probably because I was too busy wolfing it down. If you’re one of those people who refuses to eat bagels most of the time because they’re just so darn bad for you, I totally get you, but you HAVE to make an exception for this place. When I worked at Meredith (which was home to American Baby), Ess-a-Bagel was right down the street and we’d get it catered in our office every Wednesday (my goodness, I miss that!). I would always have either a 9 grain bagel with veggie cream cheese or a cinnamon raisin bagel with veggie cream cheese (I know that sounds disgusting, but I like both of those flavors and pairing them is surprisingly good) and eat it at my desk before banishing myself from carbs for the rest of the day, haha. The crazy thing is that I had no idea that this bagel place was so popular because I’d either eat their bagels in the office or snag a mini bagel on my way home from dropping off papers at my boss’s townhouse–I swear my NYC life was basically a hybrid of Younger and The Bold Type ;). So I was shocked when I visited Ess-a-Bagel on a Saturday morning a few months ago and was greeted with a line that wrapped around the block! I didn’t want to wait for 30-plus minutes, but an employee mentioned that there’s an “express line” where you can go inside and order a bagel (not toasted) and a side of cream cheese and assemble everything yourself. I did this both then and this past time in NYC because even on a Friday, the line was outrageous! However, their bagels are so, so worth it!
Milk and Cream: I kept describing this place to the friends I was visiting who thought I was referring to Milk Bar and kept getting frustrated trying to correct people–it’s a similar concept, but Milk and Cream is its own store in the West Village and has both adorable decor and AMAZING ice cream. I’ll admit that I ordered mine because I thought it was cute, but OMG, it was so worth every bite. I got the cookie dough ice cream with Cinnamon Toast Crunch mixed in and Teddy Grahams on top, and whoa, it was delish! They have countless other toppings and mix-ins, so it’s easy to change it up the next time.
Bar Primi: I made reservations for a group of us on Friday night at Bar Primi, and it’s the cutest little Italian restaurant with famous frose (I think I first heard about the concept of frose after seeing a pic from this place), and great pasta. (Thank goodness for walking 18,000-ish steps in NYC, because all of the food there is so tempting!). We started with a delicious cheese plate that we split as a table and then got perfectly-sized bowls of pasta.
ByChloe: I’m obsessed with ByChloe and actually ate there twice during my most recent visit, which isn’t uncommon for me to do when I’m up! While everything served is technically vegan, this isn’t your typical crunchy, hippie place…rather, when it comes to the demographic, it’s basically the restaurant version of SoulCycle. I almost always get the quinoa taco salad (which I ate two days in a row!) but have also tried and loved the avocado toast, and my friend Molly got the mac and cheese and really liked it as well. It’s definitely worth a visit, just note that lines can be long during lunch, since it’s a popular grab and go place, too.
The Honeywell: My friend Austin and I trekked all the way up to 145th Street to get drinks at this spot, which she had been to last summer when looking at an apartment. She told all of our friends about the awesome lava lamp drinks (some kind of cocktail served in a lava lamp shaped glass), and I’d been wanting to go there ever since! The drink was strong and cost $15, but it was definitely worth it for the portion and the overall experience of drinking out of a lava lamp–people kept asking me where I was when I Snapchatted them. (The bathroom also had gorgeous palm leaf wallpaper, but it was too dark in there to get a picture). We got some appetizers there for dinner before my train before getting another drink at Harlem Public next door. We wished that we’d waited to eat there, because they had a much better selection of food…next time!